How to Calculate Your Actual Return for Box 3

Box 3 actual return, step by step: the formula, two worked examples, and when the counter-evidence scheme lowers your Dutch tax bill on investments.

Zune.Money Team9 min read

Your Box 3 actual return is what your savings and investments really earned in a calendar year: interest, dividends and rent, plus the change in value between 1 January and 31 December, minus the interest you paid on Box 3 debts. If that number is lower than the deemed (fictional) return the Belastingdienst uses, you can report it and pay tax on the lower amount.

For 2025 the deemed return on investments is 5.88%. Anyone whose portfolio did worse than that has a reason to run the numbers. Below is the formula, two worked examples, and the one trap that makes most small portfolios lose the comparison.

Calculator, printed broker statement and a pencil on a pale oak desk, used to calculate a Box 3 actual return

What is the Box 3 actual return?

The actual return (werkelijk rendement) is the total financial result of everything you hold in Box 3 over one year. It exists because the Hoge Raad ruled that taxing people on returns they never made breaks their property rights. The background is in our piece on why Box 3 was ruled unconstitutional.

Since then the law gives you a counter-evidence scheme (tegenbewijsregeling). The deemed-return system stays the default. You get the actual-return route only if you show that your real return was lower.

What counts, per asset type:

AssetActual return
SavingsInterest received
Shares, ETFs, bondsDividend + value on 31 Dec − value on 1 Jan − purchases + sales
CryptoSame formula as shares
Rental propertyNet rent + change in WOZ value
Box 3 debtsInterest paid, as a negative

Two details matter more than they look. Unrealised gains count. A share you never sold still adds its price rise to your return. And in principle you cannot deduct costs such as fund fees or advisory fees as a separate item.

How to calculate your Box 3 actual return, step by step

The formula for investments looks odd until you see why purchases and sales are in it. Money you add to your account is not return, so it comes out. Money you take out by selling left the portfolio, so it goes back in. What remains is the real gain or loss.

  1. Write down the value of each account on 1 January. Use the euro value your broker reports. For DEGIRO, the annual report gives the portfolio value at the start and end of the year.
  2. Write down the value on 31 December. Same accounts, same method.
  3. Add up your purchases and sales during the year. These come from your transaction history, not the annual report. Every buy is a purchase, every sell is a sale.
  4. Add the income. Dividends, interest, net rent. The Belastingdienst examples do not split gross and net dividends, so ask a tax advisor which figure fits your return if foreign withholding tax was taken.
  5. Subtract interest paid on Box 3 debts. The debt threshold does not apply here, so all of it counts.

Add the results for all your assets. If the total is negative, your actual return for the year is zero.

Worked example: the Belastingdienst's own numbers

The Belastingdienst publishes calculation examples for the actual return. Their 2025 case has €100,000 in savings and €150,000 in investments.

ItemAmount
Interest on savings€1,200
Dividend received€500
Investments on 31 Dec€160,000
Investments on 1 Jan−€150,000
Purchases during the year−€1,200
Sales during the year+€3,000
Actual return€13,500

The deemed return for the same person is €7,838. The actual return is higher, so reporting it gives no benefit. The investments gained about 8% in a year where the deemed rate was 5.88%, and on top of that the allowance worked in the taxpayer's favour (more on that below).

The same page shows the other side: someone with only €150,000 in savings and €1,050 of interest. Their deemed return is €1,264, so reporting the actual €1,050 lowers the bill.

Worked example: a down year at DEGIRO

Here is a case closer to a typical retail investor. A DEGIRO portfolio of ETFs and a few US stocks, plus a savings buffer. The year was poor: a weak dollar and a sell-off in tech took the portfolio down, even after monthly buys. (These are illustrative numbers, not a forecast.)

ItemAmount
Savings on 1 Jan€20,000
Interest on savings€300
DEGIRO portfolio on 1 Jan€80,000
DEGIRO portfolio on 31 Dec€78,000
Purchases during the year€6,000
Sales during the year€0
Dividends€900

Investments: €900 + €78,000 − €80,000 − €6,000 + €0 = −€7,100. Add the €300 interest and the total is −€6,800. The actual return counts as zero, so there is no Box 3 tax for the year.

The deemed calculation for 2025 gives a different picture. Savings at 1.37% is €274. Investments at 5.88% is €4,704. Total wealth is €100,000, and after the €57,684 allowance, 42.3% of the deemed return is taxable: about €2,107. At 36%, that is roughly €758 in tax on a year in which the portfolio lost money.

Notice the trap in the first example. The portfolio value fell by only €2,000, which looks small. The €6,000 of monthly buys hid a bigger loss. If you only compare start and end balances, you will underestimate how much the counter-evidence scheme can save you. This is the most common error we see.

When reporting your actual return pays off

The comparison is not "my return versus 5.88%". It is your full actual return versus your deemed return after the tax-free allowance. And the actual return gets no allowance. The Belastingdienst confirms the allowance applies only to the deemed calculation.

This changes the break-even point a lot for smaller portfolios. Take €100,000, all in investments, for 2025:

  • Deemed return before the allowance: €5,880
  • Taxable share after the €57,684 allowance: 42.3%
  • Deemed Box 3 income: about €2,488

So your actual return has to fall below €2,488, or about 2.5%, before reporting helps. Not below 5.88%. The larger your wealth, the closer the break-even moves to the headline rate. With €1 million the allowance barely matters.

The rates for the deemed calculation:

YearInvestmentsSavingsDebtsAllowance per personRate
20255.88%1.37%2.70%€57,68436%
20266.00%not finalnot final€59,35736%
20276.37% (formula)not finalnot finalabout €60,280 (planned)36%

The 2027 figures come from the Belastingplan 2027, which the Tweede Kamer passed on 12 November 2026. The Eerste Kamer still has to vote, and the savings and debt rates are published later each year.

Where to submit: tax return or opgaaf werkelijk rendement

The route depends on the year.

  • 2025 and later: you report the actual return inside your income tax return (aangifte inkomstenbelasting). The return asks for it when you have Box 3 assets.
  • 2020 to 2024: you use the online opgaaf werkelijk rendement form in Mijn Belastingdienst. One form per year.
  • 2017 to 2019: a separate form on the Belastingdienst website. Whether you still qualify depends on objections you filed back then.

You do not attach proof with the form. Keep your broker statements anyway, because the Belastingdienst can ask for them. In every case it uses the more favourable of the two amounts, so filing never raises your tax.

Getting the numbers out of DEGIRO

Steps 1 and 2 are easy: the DEGIRO annual report shows your portfolio value on both dates. Step 3 is where people give up. The annual report does not list total purchases and sales in a form you can paste into the formula, so you end up adding rows from the Transactions export by hand. Our guide to tracking a DEGIRO portfolio shows where that export lives.

If you hold US stocks, there is one more wrinkle. The euro value of a dollar position moves with the exchange rate, and that movement is part of your actual return. A weak dollar year can push your return below the deemed rate even when the shares rose in dollars. We covered the mechanics in how EUR/USD moves your portfolio returns.

A portfolio tracker does most of this for you. Upload the DEGIRO Transactions CSV to Zune.Money's DEGIRO tracker and you see your holdings, buys, sells and dividends in one place, which are the raw inputs of the formula. It does not file anything for you. It saves the hour of adding up rows.

What to do before 31 December 2026

Your 2026 tax return, filed in spring 2027, will need the value of every account on 31 December 2026. Three small actions now save work later:

  1. Save a screenshot or PDF of each account on 31 December. Brokers do produce annual reports, but banks with savings accounts and crypto exchanges are less consistent.
  2. Export your full 2026 transaction history in early January, before you forget which account held what.
  3. Do not sell just to change the 1 January value. Under the deemed system your 1 January holdings drive the tax, and under the actual-return route a sale is neutral (it goes back into the formula). Selling for tax reasons alone rarely pays. If you are thinking about it anyway, read our notes on tax-loss harvesting in Europe first, because the Dutch rules differ from most other countries.

The deemed system is not going away soon. The Wet werkelijk rendement box 3 now targets 2029 and still waits for the Eerste Kamer. Until then, the counter-evidence scheme is the only way to pay tax on what you earned instead of what the state assumes you earned. It costs you an evening with your statements once a year. In a bad year that evening can be worth several hundred euros.

This article explains how the calculation works. It is not tax advice. For your own return, check the current figures with the Belastingdienst or a tax advisor.

Frequently asked questions

Do unrealised gains count in the Box 3 actual return?

Yes. Under the counter-evidence scheme the value change between 1 January and 31 December counts whether you sold or not. A share that rose €2,000 and that you still hold adds €2,000 to your actual return, the same as a realised gain.

Can I carry a Box 3 loss forward to next year?

No. If your actual return for the year is negative, it counts as zero for that year and you pay no Box 3 tax. The loss does not move to the next year. Losses on one asset do offset gains on another inside the same year.

Can reporting my actual return make my Box 3 tax higher?

No. The Belastingdienst compares your actual return with the deemed return and uses the amount that is better for you. If your actual return is higher, it keeps the deemed calculation. The only cost of reporting is the time it takes to gather the numbers.

Does crypto count in the Box 3 actual return?

Yes. Crypto falls under other assets in Box 3, and the Belastingdienst uses the same formula as for shares: value on 31 December, minus value on 1 January, minus purchases, plus sales, plus any income. Unrealised price changes count.

Is the counter-evidence scheme still available for 2027?

Yes, as far as the current plans go. The new system based on actual returns now targets 1 January 2029 and is not law yet. Until it starts, the deemed-return system stays, and you can keep reporting a lower actual return each year.

Related articles

Wooden desk with Dutch tulip in a vase, official document, and notebook in soft morning light
netherlandstaxes

Box 3: Netherlands' Wealth Tax Ruled Unconstitutional

On Christmas Eve 2021, Dutch investors got an unusual present. The Hoge Raad (Dutch Supreme Court) ruled that Box 3 — the country's wealth tax on savings and i...

Laptop showing a DEGIRO portfolio tracker dashboard with total return, dividends, and allocation next to a notebook
degiroportfolio

How to Track Your DEGIRO Portfolio in 2026 (Full Guide)

DEGIRO's app shows you what your portfolio is worth right now and whether you're up or down against what you paid. Then it stops. To actually track your DEGIRO...

Desk calendar open on December next to a cup of black coffee and a brass pen, a reminder of the year-end deadline for tax-loss harvesting in Europe
taxeseurope

Tax-Loss Harvesting in Europe: Year-End Guide by Country

Tax-loss harvesting means selling an investment that is below its purchase price before 31 December, so the realised loss reduces the tax on gains you made thi...